APPLICATIONS TO ELITE UNIVERSITIES | Should Head Teachers Be the Gatekeepers of Oxbridge and the LSE? by Ashbourne Independent Sixth Form College, London
Ashbourne A Level College, London - logo
Ashbourne A Level College London
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram
+44(0)207 937 3858

+44(0)207 937 3858

Primary menu

Skip to primary content
Skip to secondary content
Menu
  • A levels
    • Close
    • A levels
      • A levels at Ashbourne
      • A level subjects
      • A level intensive courses
      • A level retakes (resits)
      • A level one year
      • A level transfers
      • A level Easter Revision courses
      • A level exam results
      • Admissions
    • Specialist Programmes
      • Online Distance Learning
      • Medical School Programme (AMSP)
      • Engineering Programme (AEP)
      • Finance Programme (AFP)
      • Oxbridge Programme (AOP)
      • Art Programme (AAP)
      • Extended project (EPQ)
      • Music at Ashbourne
      • Drama & Theatre Studies
    • Close
  • GCSEs
    • Close
    • GCSEs
      • GCSE courses at Ashbourne College, London
      • GCSE Subjects
      • GCSE Easter Revision Courses
      • GCSE Exam Results
      • Admissions
    • Close
  • Easter Revision
    • Close
    • Easter Revision
      • Easter Revision introduction
      • Course dates, times and fees
      • Course timetable & enrolment
      • A level Easter revision courses
      • GCSE Easter revision courses
      • Easter Revision testimonials
      • Revision hints and tips
    • Close
  • International
    • Close
    • International Students
      • International Students introduction
      • A level courses at Ashbourne
      • GCSE courses at Ashbourne
      • Online Distance Learning at Ashbourne
      • Visas to study at Ashbourne
      • Best high school in London
      • Apply now
    • Close
  • About us
    • Close
    • About Us
      • Why choose Ashbourne?
      • Best college in London
      • Personal tutors
      • Staff
      • The Proprietor
      • Facilities
      • Location
    • Results
      • A level Exam results
      • GCSE Exam Results
      • A level results league tables
      • University Destinations
      • University and Careers
      • Ofsted accreditation
      • Testimonials
    • College Resources
      • Ashbourne Portal
      • College Policies »
      • College Resources
      • Safeguarding Resources
      • Ashbourne Staff Documents
      • Supercurricular Library
    • Activities and Events
      • Open Evening
      • Christmas Revue
      • Activities and Events
      • European Trips
    • Blogs/Social
      • Ashbourne College Blog
      • PSHEE Blog
      • Facebook
      • Twitter
      • YouTube
      • Instagram
    • Close
  • Admissions
    • Close
    • Admissions
      • Admissions introduction
      • Prospectus
      • Fees
      • Term dates
    • Admissions
      • UK student admissions
      • International student admissions
      • Ashbourne Virtual Open Events
    • Admissions
      • Accommodation
      • A level course length options
      • A level scholarships
    • Close
  • Jobs
  • Contact Us
    • Close
    • Contact Us
      • Contact Us
      • Our location
      • College location map
      • The Proprietor
      • Registered company details
    • Close
  •  

Post navigation

← Previous Next →

Applications to Elite Universities in England

Home » College Articles » Applications to Elite Universities in England
View all College Advice Articles...

Should Head Teachers Be the Gatekeepers of Oxbridge and the LSE?

As recent articles in the national press have highlighted, parents are becoming increasingly demanding, even to the point of litigation.This trend has been linked to the presence of overseas students and their oligarchical parents in our private schools, but the truth is that in the last two decades an increasingly competitive society and a decline in deference to teachers have changed the outlook of British families as well. In no area are parents more demanding than in their children’s applications to higher education: sometimes they even expect schools to provide unrealistic references and grade predictions, both of which need to be very high if an application to an elite university is to be successful. However, it would be unjust to blame the parents for the pressure that schools face when recommending students for universities. It is genuinely the case that the future of the young person is to a large extent in the hands of the school, and this, regardless of the input from parents, is in itself a tremendous responsibility.

At Ashbourne College we acknowledge that we have fundamental duties to our students and to our own professional integrity. Ashbourne is committed to a student-first policy: within reason we will do whatever is in our power to ensure that students succeed. However, we also have a duty to behave with integrity in order to ensure that Ashbourne’s good name is reinforced and never compromised. These aims are of course complementary since unrealistic recommendations would diminish the value of our references as a whole.

It is one of our most important duties to ensure that each student applies to a university or degree course that is appropriate to their ability and preparation. If a student has not prepared properly, as would be indicated by underperformance in examinations and/or assignments, we will not recommend them. Of course potential is important and in general if a student shows ambition and commitment we will be as optimistic as we reasonably can when predicting grades.

In general it is not worth applying to Oxbridge unless the student is likely to obtain all grade As with at least one A* grade (although humanities departments at Oxford do not make a distinction between A and A* when making offers). This must be seen in the context of recent admission statistics: in 2012 80+% of students entering Cambridge had 4 or more A* grades at A level, while in Oxford the figure was 70+ %. However, even if a student is likely to obtain the highest grades, we will still not recommend them for Oxbridge unless they have the necessary confidence and flair in order to cope with the interview procedure. They must also have undertaken appropriate research into their proposed course, such as project work and reading outside the syllabus.

The same policy concerning grades and research applies to applications for institutions such as Imperial College, UCL and LSE, which are consistently ranked among the top ten universities in the world.

Although we are scrupulous in our references, we are frustrated by the obtuseness of the application procedures of some of Britain’s elite universities. Since they all reject a considerable number of students who have been predicted extremely high A Level grades, we believe that they should all implement their own tests in order to assess applications fairly. Otherwise, an unfair degree of pressure is put on school staff, who not only have to consider the future of their students when writing references but also have to phrase their recommendations in a way that enables universities to make fine distinctions between competing candidates of high calibre.

At the moment Oxford University has admissions tests that are used for most subjects in the process by which students are short-listed for interview. However, this is not generally the case with Cambridge University, while LSE does not arrange tests for its applicants (except in particular circumstances such as mature students on access courses). It is our submission that this is unjustifiable, in particular for exceptionally competitive degree courses such as Economics. We have noticed that excellent applicants often do not obtain offers for such courses, no doubt after close consideration by the university of previous exam results, subject combinations, personal statements and so forth. Nonetheless, given the generally high standard of the applicants, some other form of assessment by the university is needed in order to ensure that acceptance and rejection decisions are never arbitrary.

As principals, head teachers and other senior staff at schools, we are content to stand at the gates of our nation’s august universities, verifying the academic credentials of students, their dedication and intellectual curiosity. However, we do believe that we should expect a similar level of interaction and diligence from these institutions themselves.

 

This entry was posted by Ashbourne College. Bookmark the permalink.

Ashbourne Social Channels

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • Instagram

Ashbourne A level College London

  • One of the best A level colleges in London
  • Strong exam results - 2011-2020, 47% A*A
  • 54% of graduates at Russell Group Universities
  • Exceptional facilities
  • Individual attention
  • Great location

DOWNLOAD PROSPECTUS APPLY NOW

video-ashbourne-college-london
Watch our introductory video

Subscribe by RSS

  You can also subscribe to our latest news updates using our RSS feed.

  • A Level College London
  • GCSE Courses in London
  • Easter Revision courses in London
  • Independent High School London
  • About Ashbourne Sixth Form College
  • Admissions to Ashbourne College
  • A Level Subjects
  • GCSE Subjects
  • Medical School Programme (AMSP)
  • Oxbridge Programme (AOP)
  • Engineering Programme (AEP)
  • Finance Programme (AFP)
  • Jobs at Ashbourne College
  • Cookie Policy
  • Sitemap
  • Trademarks & Copyright
  • Website Disclaimer
  • Website Privacy Notice

Ashbourne Sixth Form College
17 Old Court Place
Kensington
London W8 4PL
United Kingdom
+44(0)207 937 3858
admissions@ashbournecollege.co.uk
Location map

The cookie notice has been accepted. Click here to review our Cookie Policy
A level College in London | 私立一所大学,伦敦 | Swasta A kolej tahap, London | Частный колледж уровня, Лондон | Cao đẳng A-level tư nhân ở London
Copyright © 2021 Ashbourne A Level College London. All Rights Reserved.
Web design and development by OlleyDesign & WebSanity
Ashbourne A level College is taking an extensive range of measures to mitigate against Coronavirus (COVID-19). Read more...
This website uses cookies to gather anonymous website usage information. Accept Find out more...
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled

Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

Non-necessary

Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.

SAVE & ACCEPT